12 comments
Not resolved

I was told that this $ 6.39 charge on my bill was for them to recover some of their tax cost to be in business in the state of Texas.Also I,m having to pay $ 3.63 extra for a "Regional Sports Fee", for sports channels that were in my package, something about how it is in Texas.

I've never had a recovery fee on any net work before. Even on a cel phone that fee is just a few cents per phone on AT&T, their parent company.

To get out from under this mess it would cost $ 320.00.As fast as I can check out the other services and compare getting out and breaking even with another service at a cheaper rate for same length of time I will try it.

Review about: Att Switch To Att Deal.

I didn't like: Unhappy, Incompetency and training of customer service staff.

Review #988338 is a subjective opinion of a user.

1.0
Coverage Area
Customer service
Product or Service Quality
Diversity of Products or Services
Website
Advertised vs Delivered
Style and Design
Billing Practices
Exchange, Refund and Cancellation Policy
Price Affordability
Reliability
Value for money
Warranty
Discounts and Special Offers
PRODUCT OR SERVICE Att Switch To Att Deal
Reason of Review / Monetary Loss Poor customer service / $160
Preferred solution Price reduction

Had an Experience with Att?

Submit review

Comments

Comment as anonymous or
Terms of Service
Post Comment
Cancel
Dave
Any fee such as the FCC cost recovery fee that was not in the original agreement is a unilateral change in the conditions of the contract. They can either remove the charge or the other proper remedy is recession of the contract with each party being put into the position that they were prior to entering into the contract. In short, you are not bound to the contract if they insist on changing the conditions without your consent. But you do have to object and insist on not paying and if they refuse insist on a recission of the contract. The contract or terms of service operate on "Qui tacet consentit" or silence means assent. If you do not object, then you agree to any change or charge imposed.
Miss Betsy
#1275325
A "franchise fee" is something Time Warner Cable has always charged - until very recently after being bought by Spectrum. We as customers were forced to pay THEIR tax for being permitted to monopolize New York for decades. Pretty crazy.
Anonymous
Katy, Texas, United States #1274808
By law, if a company represents a fee as a state regulatory assessment, that fee MUST be paid to the state. If not, it's illegal...period. If you feel you are being illegally assessed a fee, you need to file a complaint with the attorney general's office.
https://www.texasattorneygeneral.gov/cpd/consumer-protection
This is how the legal process works. And if Ken Paxton receives 1000 complaints, he will give it his attention. BTW this wouldn't the first time AT&T had a run in with the FCC or it's first class action lawsuit.
Hatetaxes
Magnolia, Texas, United States #1274197
I called Directv today (1/21/2017) because my Directv bill in Jan 2017 had a $3.44 charge for Texas State Cost Recovery Fee. I asked why this month and what was it for. The answer I got was WRONG. She said it was an FCC charge and the percent was 3.447 percent. Taking the free ($3.44) and dividing by .03447, you get $99.80. Well, that wasn't my bill. So I don't know what they are charging it on, somethings, not others. It makes sense that Directv is now passing along its TX Franchise tax bill to customers, but why now? Their accountants just figured it out to do this?! It just ticks me off that when you call, the person you talk to, doesn't have a clue what charges are for. I was told to call the 'government.' BTW, the delivery charge on my electric bill (TXU) was supposed to be calculated by kilowatts used X a specific rate PLUS and flat fee. I recalculated the charge for the last 4 months, and all 4 were wrong. There are crediting my account. If you have TXU, recalculate the delivery charge on your bill. My son's was wrong. I think this is a class action suit waiting to happen.
Anonymous
Ottawa, Ontario, Canada #1272413
I have Directv service and a charge of $2.73 appeared on my January 07th statement, here's what I found out what the charge is for:
According to a State of Texas Comptroller notice, Texas businesses may charge customers a cost-recovery" fee in order to recoup the Texas franchise tax the State of Texas collects from businesses owners. While businesses who charge customers a Cost-Recovery fee must be careful to use specific "recovery fee" wording, so as to not imply the charge is a direct state tax on consumers, they are, in effect, passing along the Texas franchise tax the state collects from them.
Many companies simply work the cost of the Texas franchise tax into product margins, but the Texas state comptroller says a specific recovery fee may be charged with the explicit purpose of recovering the tax expense.
Comptroller website: A company choosing to bill customers a Recovery Charge may explain to its customers that the charge is made in order to recoup money paid by the company for taxes imposed on it. The company may not, however, represent the charge as a tax imposed directly on the customer. To this end, the Recovery Charge must not appear in the "Government Fees and Taxes" (or similar section) of the customer's bill, invoice or contract. Further, the company should disclose that the Recovery Charge is not a tax the company is required to collect from its customers by law.
The Texas franchise tax applies to all business entities except sole proprietorships
... Show more
Chris
to Anonymous Burnet, Texas, United States #1273676
Thank you for the info. On hold with them now for someone to explain this charge to me. The first rep says "I don't know, call back in tomorrow and we will have an answer" what?!!! No, you tell me now!!! Still in hold...
Anonymous
to Chris Mckinney, Texas, United States #1275358
Don't bother calling Directv back - you won't get any information. I was advised to email taxsupport@directv.com or contact my state legislature.
Companies must pay a Franchise Tax to operate in TX. The "Texas State Cost Recovery Fee" on the bill is being used to recover their cost. That means the consumer is footing the bill for Directv to operate in TX. So we are paying for their service (which all packages are going up $2 - $6 this month) PLUS a tax Directv owes TX.
The Franchise Tax started in 2008 and it wasn't passed through to the customer until Jan 2017. It's a cost of doing business so they USED to just build it into the cost of their service. But now they have added the recovery fee to our bill and prices are going up. It looks like they are double and triple dipping the consumer.
Anonymous
to Anonymous Boca Raton, Florida, United States #1275318
On hold with Directv now. Thanks for your explanation, I'm sure it's much better than what I'll get from Directv.
It appears to me that the AT&T accountants have combed through Directv's books and found some additional revenue they can legally collect that they weren't getting before.
Directv hasn't been the same since AT&T took over. I'll be looking for another service. If anyone in TX knows of a better provider, let us know!
Brett
to Anonymous Brookhaven, Mississippi, United States #1277786
Good info. I think I win the prize, though. My fee was $9.11. That's the highest I've read so far. Not really a contest I was hoping to be the leader in.
Anonymous
San Antonio, Texas, United States #1271969
Mine is over $8.00 and I noticed they are taxing it. I am only third month into this and thought I would be locked into a contract that would not change in cost, in return if I tried to cancel early would pay a hefty fee. They are being allowed to increase my bill and disguise it as necessary fees. Customer service has no clue about this and tells me they are helpless.
Please put this all over the internet, this may just be the beginning.

You May Also Like

"Hello my name is Valerie Grier I am very unsettling with Att wireless cell phone service i have to let my service go with ATT i didn't want to but..." Read more
"I had also had a bad experience with AT&T U-verse internet..... I had signed up for new internet service at my house. The advertised speed was 75 Mbps for $35 for..." Read more
"a telephone pole on our block burned, the whole block has been out of service. Each time I call the 800 number, I'm outsourced to some random country where..." Read more
"I dropped Att as a service provider last year because of many of the complaints others have. Random dead end phone numbers, horrible oversees customer service, bad pricing in..." Read more
" I got coc 8 max base from my school friend.at sri Lankan rupies 2500 .so after month he change password .plz give back my account .plzz give me ecount..." Read more
"AutoTopsDirect Mazda miata convertible top is Junk Miata replacement tops are a FIRE HAZARD. Refused warranty service for faulty rear defroster solder. Smoke, melted vinyl and shattered window. Lloyd (their..." Read more
"We just picked up a brand new keyston fusion 371 yesterday. We loved this service when we were buying the camper, But what we went through yesterday was not good...." Read more
"Garnier is a disgusting company that I would never recommend. After over a year of not dying my hair, I decided to add a blue tint to my black hair...." Read more